Skip to content

Local SEO, Paid Media

9 Reasons Your Business Gets Out-of-State Calls (And How to Fix Them)

Getting calls from customers outside your service area? Learn how to fix Google Ads targeting, optimize your Google Business Profile, reduce spam calls, and attract more qualified local leads.

Imagine running a plumbing company in Austin, Texas, only to spend your morning answering calls from people looking for plumbers in Phoenix, Arizona, or Miami, Florida.

Your business serves a specific geographic area. You have a local phone number, a Google Business Profile, and a website describing your services. So why are people from other states calling you?

For local service businesses, unwanted out-of-state calls can waste time, frustrate staff, and make it harder to identify genuine leads. If you’re running Google Ads, they can also indicate that your advertising budget isn’t being spent as efficiently as it could be.

The good news is that these calls often have an identifiable cause. Your advertising settings, website content, business listings, call tracking, or even the callers themselves could be responsible.

In this guide, we’ll explain how to diagnose the source of unwanted calls, correct the underlying problems, and attract more customers from the areas you actually serve.

Why Is Your Local Service Business Getting Calls From Other States?

There isn’t one universal explanation for out-of-state calls. Several different mechanisms can produce the same symptom, and each requires a different solution.

For example, a roofing company in Dallas might receive calls from homeowners in Oklahoma because its Google Ads campaign reaches people interested in Dallas-area services, even when they’re physically elsewhere. Another company might receive calls from people who found an old directory listing with an incorrect phone number.

Before making changes, distinguish between three situations:

  • Unwanted leads: People genuinely need your service, but their properties are outside your coverage area.
  • Irrelevant calls: Callers are looking for a different business, service, or location.
  • Spam and misdirected calls: Robocalls, sales pitches, spoofed caller IDs, and accidental calls have little or nothing to do with your marketing strategy.

Your first objective is to determine which situation you’re dealing with.

To fix the leak in your pipeline, you need to systematically audit the most common failure points across your advertising, business listings, website, and phone systems—starting with your paid search campaigns.

Getting your geographic targeting right is only one part of building a strong local search presence. From optimising your Google Business Profile to targeting neighborhood searches and creating location-specific service pages, our complete local SEO blueprint explains how to attract more relevant customers in the areas you actually serve.

Here are the 9 most common reasons your business is attracting out-of-state calls, along with the exact fixes for each.

1. Your Google Ads Location Targeting Is Too Broad

If you’re running Google Search campaigns, location targeting is one of the first places to investigate.

Google Ads can use different location options to determine which users are eligible to see your advertisements. Depending on your campaign settings, your ads may reach people who are physically in your targeted areas, regularly visit them, or have expressed an interest in them.

That distinction matters for a local service business.

Suppose you operate an HVAC company in Charlotte, North Carolina. You want to reach homeowners in Charlotte and surrounding communities, but your campaign uses a location option that also includes people interested in your target locations.

Someone living in Atlanta who searches for HVAC services in Charlotte may qualify to see your ad. If that person calls your business, you’ve received an out-of-state call even though your campaign is operating according to its settings.

How to diagnose the problem

Open your Google Ads account and examine the settings for each relevant Search campaign.

Check:

  • The geographic locations included in the campaign.
  • Whether the campaign targets people physically present in your target locations or also includes people interested in those locations.
  • The geographic performance of your campaign.
  • Whether the search terms and ads attract customers outside your service area.

Google Ads provides location reports that can help you investigate where your ad traffic originates. The available reporting details depend on the campaign and reporting view.

How to fix it

If your business only wants customers physically located within its service area, consider using the location option that targets people in or regularly in your targeted locations.

In Google Ads, review your campaign’s location options and select the setting appropriate for your business. Also remove locations you don’t serve and consider excluding regions that consistently produce irrelevant traffic.

Remember that location targeting is based on Google’s available signals and isn’t perfectly accurate. A location setting can reduce unwanted traffic, but it cannot guarantee that every caller will be local.

2. Your Local Services Ads Cover the Wrong Areas

Google Local Services Ads are another potential source of unwanted calls.

These ads can generate direct calls and messages from prospective customers. If your service areas or advertised job types are configured too broadly, you may receive leads from people you cannot serve.

For example, a pest control company based in Tampa might serve Tampa, Brandon, and Clearwater. If its advertising settings include additional cities that the company doesn’t actually cover, people searching in those areas may be able to contact the business.

There’s another important detail: Local Services Ads can sometimes appear for people outside a selected area when their searches demonstrate interest in that area.

Consequently, the fact that a caller is outside your service area doesn’t automatically mean your settings are incorrect.

How to diagnose the problem

Sign in to your Local Services Ads account and review:

  • The cities, counties, and ZIP codes included in your service areas.
  • The job types you’re advertising.
  • Whether unwanted leads come from specific locations.
  • Whether the calls originate from your Local Services Ads listing.

If you use Local Services Ads, examine the lead information available in your account to identify geographic patterns.

How to fix it

Remove service areas you don’t intend to cover and disable irrelevant job types.

For example, if you only provide residential HVAC repairs, review whether the advertised services accurately reflect that offering.

If unwanted calls continue, investigate how people outside your service area are discovering your listing rather than repeatedly changing the same settings.

3. Your Google Business Profile Has Incorrect Service Areas

Your Google Business Profile helps Google understand where your business operates and what it offers.

If you run a service-area business, such as a plumber who travels to customers, you can specify the areas you serve through your profile.

An inaccurate service area can create confusion about your coverage.

Imagine that your electrical contracting company operates in Denver, Colorado. You serve Denver and several nearby communities, but your profile includes locations across a much wider portion of Colorado.

That broader area may communicate a service range you cannot realistically support.

However, an important distinction is necessary: Google Business Profile service areas are not a direct switch that guarantees your business will or won’t appear to people in other states.

Google considers several signals when determining which businesses to display. Correcting your service area helps communicate your actual coverage, but it won’t resolve every source of unwanted calls.

While fixing your service area prevents confusion for out-of-state searchers, remember that service areas alone don’t dictate your local ranking map. For a complete breakdown on how proximity and categories affect your map listings, read our guide on 10 Reasons Your Business Isn’t Showing Up on the Google Maps 3-Pack.

How to diagnose the problem

Open your Google Business Profile and review its location information.

Check:

  • Whether the listed business address is accurate.
  • Whether your business is correctly configured as a storefront, service-area business, or hybrid business.
  • Whether the service areas reflect the places you genuinely serve.
  • Whether your phone number belongs to your business and connects callers to the right team.

Google allows eligible service-area businesses to specify up to 20 service areas using cities, postal codes, or other supported geographic areas. The overall area generally shouldn’t extend beyond approximately two hours of driving time from the business’s base, although some businesses may qualify for larger service areas.

How to fix it

Remove service areas you don’t serve and keep your profile information accurate.

If you operate from a residential address and don’t receive customers there, follow Google’s requirements for hiding the address of an eligible service-area business.

Don’t create additional Google Business Profiles for cities where you don’t have eligible business locations. Adding fake locations to attract local calls can violate Google’s guidelines and put your profiles at risk.

4. Your Website Targets Locations You Don’t Actually Serve

Your website can influence how prospective customers discover your business.

Suppose your company offers roof repairs in Indianapolis, Indiana, but your website contains pages targeting dozens of cities across the country.

Those pages may attract visitors searching for roofing services in locations you cannot serve. If your phone number is prominently displayed, some of those visitors may call.

This doesn’t mean that mentioning another city automatically causes out-of-state calls. The problem is whether your website communicates an accurate picture of your services and coverage.

How to diagnose the problem

Review your website’s:

  • Service pages.
  • Location pages.
  • Page titles and meta descriptions.
  • Contact information.
  • Calls to action.
  • Organic search traffic by landing page and geographic location, where the available analytics support that analysis.

Look for pages targeting locations outside your actual service area.

Also check whether you have generic pages that imply nationwide coverage despite operating locally.

How to fix it

Align your website content with your genuine service area.

For example, a landscaping company in Nashville, Tennessee, could create useful pages for Nashville and nearby communities it actually serves.

Each page should provide relevant information about the services offered and the location being discussed. Avoid publishing large numbers of near-identical city pages simply to capture more searches.

If you no longer serve a location, update or remove misleading content and handle any resulting URL changes appropriately.

The goal is to attract qualified local visitors, not simply increase traffic from every possible location.

5. Your Business Is Listed Incorrectly on Third-Party Directories

Your business information may appear on directories, review platforms, industry websites, and other online listings.

If one of those sources displays an incorrect phone number or outdated service information, people looking for another business may end up calling you.

For example, imagine that a home cleaning company in Columbus, Ohio, changes its phone number. An older directory listing still displays the previous number, which has since been assigned to a different business.

Someone searching for that other business could accidentally call the cleaning company.

This is different from receiving a legitimate lead from outside your service area. The underlying issue is inaccurate business information.

Inaccurate listings don’t just misdirect calls—they often trigger negative reviews from frustrated searchers who reached the wrong business. If bad details or misdirected leads have led to poor ratings on your profile, see our guide on How to Handle a 1-Star Google Review Before It Kills Your Local Rankings.

How to diagnose the problem

When you receive an irrelevant call, ask the caller where they found your number.

Did they find it through:

  • Google Search or Google Maps?
  • A business directory?
  • A social media profile?
  • Your website?
  • An advertisement?
  • A previous text message or saved contact?

You can also search for your business name and phone number to identify listings that may contain outdated information.

How to fix it

Correct inaccurate information at its source.

Update your website, Google Business Profile, and the directories you can access. If another business has taken over a phone number previously used by your company, investigate which listings still display the old number.

Maintain consistent, accurate contact information across the platforms where your business appears.

You don’t need to submit your information to every directory on the internet. Prioritize relevant platforms and listings that customers actually use.

6. Your Phone Number Is Being Spoofed or Targeted by Spam

Not every unwanted call is caused by local SEO or advertising.

Some calls originate from robocallers, telemarketers, scammers, or automated systems. Others involve caller ID spoofing, where the displayed number doesn’t accurately identify the caller.

In some cases, your business number may also be used in spoofed calls made to other people.

This can create a confusing situation. You might receive calls from people in different states asking why you contacted them, even though nobody at your business made those calls.

How to diagnose the problem

Look for patterns.

Possible warning signs include:

  • Callers saying you contacted them first.
  • Repeated calls with no clear connection to your services.
  • Automated messages or suspicious sales pitches.
  • A large increase in brief or disconnected calls.
  • Callers reporting that your number appeared on their caller ID even though you didn’t call them.

No single symptom proves spoofing, but repeated patterns can help distinguish spam from genuine leads.

How to fix it

If the calls appear to be spam, review the options available through your phone carrier or business phone provider.

Depending on your setup, you may be able to use spam filtering, call screening, or call-blocking features.

For a business phone system, consider whether an interactive voice response menu or receptionist screening process would help direct genuine customers to the right team.

For example, a roofing company might ask callers to select whether they’re requesting a new estimate, following up on an existing project, or calling about something else.

Avoid blocking entire states simply because some unwanted calls originate there. That could prevent legitimate customers from reaching you.

If other people report receiving calls from your number that you didn’t make, contact your phone provider to investigate possible spoofing.

7. Your Call Tracking Setup Is Creating Confusion

Call tracking is useful for understanding which marketing activities generate phone enquiries. However, a poorly configured setup can make it harder to interpret those calls.

For example, you might use one tracking number for Google Ads and another on your website. If the numbers are incorrectly configured, forwarded calls may be attributed to the wrong source.

A call tracking report might also show a caller’s area code without accurately establishing where the person is physically located.

An out-of-state area code does not necessarily mean an out-of-state customer.

Someone living in California may retain a New York phone number after moving. Similarly, a customer temporarily traveling outside your service area might call about a property located within it.

The number alone isn’t enough to determine whether the lead is relevant.

How to diagnose the problem

Review your call tracking platform and phone system.

Check:

  • Which tracking number received the call.
  • Which marketing source was attributed to the call.
  • Whether the call was forwarded correctly.
  • Whether the caller actually requested a service in your coverage area.
  • Whether duplicate records or incorrect source attribution exist.

Compare your call tracking data with your Google Ads reports, website analytics, and available lead records.

How to fix it

Make sure each tracking number is configured correctly and routes calls to the intended destination.

Use the appropriate attribution methods for your marketing channels, and test the setup after making changes.

Most importantly, classify calls based on their actual relevance rather than the area code alone.

A caller with an out-of-state number who needs an HVAC repair at a property in your service area may be a perfectly good lead.

8. Your Advertising Attracts People Who Want Information Rather Than Local Service

Sometimes, your geographic settings are correct, but your advertising still attracts the wrong audience.

This can happen when your ads use broad messaging that doesn’t communicate the intended service area or customer need.

For example, a pest control company in Sacramento might advertise “Affordable Pest Control Services” without mentioning its location or the specific services it provides.

That message may attract a wide range of searchers, including people looking for information, comparing providers in other states, or researching services they don’t currently need.

How to diagnose the problem

Review your Google Ads search terms and the landing pages associated with your campaigns.

Look for searches that suggest the user wants something different from the service you offer.

For example:

  • People searching for jobs rather than hiring a contractor.
  • People researching a service without intending to purchase it.
  • People looking for providers in another city.
  • People searching for services you don’t offer.

Not every informational search is irrelevant, but you should understand which searches are generating calls and whether those calls lead to viable opportunities.

How to fix it

Make your ads more specific.

A local HVAC company might use messaging such as “AC Repair in Sacramento” rather than generic copy that could apply to a nationwide provider.

Ensure your landing pages clearly communicate your service area, available services, and next steps.

Where appropriate, add negative keywords to prevent your Search campaigns from appearing for irrelevant queries. Negative keywords should be selected carefully because overly broad exclusions can block useful searches.

If a campaign attracts a high volume of irrelevant calls despite accurate location settings, review its keyword strategy, match types, ad messaging, and conversion data.

9. Your Website or Ads Make It Difficult to Understand Where You Operate

Sometimes, the issue is not that your business is reaching the wrong people. It’s that prospective customers cannot tell whether you serve them.

A website might list several cities without explaining the actual coverage area. An advertisement might promote a service without identifying the location. A landing page might prominently display a phone number but provide little information about eligibility or availability.

This creates uncertainty.

For example, a mobile auto repair company serving the greater Phoenix area may receive calls from customers in Tucson because its website doesn’t clearly explain its geographic limits.

How to diagnose the problem

Review your website and advertising from the perspective of a potential customer.

Ask:

  • Is the service area easy to find?
  • Are the cities or communities you serve clearly identified?
  • Do your ads communicate the relevant location?
  • Can visitors quickly determine whether you provide the service they need?
  • Is your phone number presented alongside accurate service-area information?

How to fix it

Make your coverage clear and consistent.

Include your service area on relevant service pages and contact pages. Where appropriate, mention the primary city and surrounding communities in your ad copy.

For example:

Residential Plumbing in Austin, TX

Serving Austin, Round Rock, and Cedar Park.

Call to request service and confirm availability.

This messaging helps prospective customers understand the coverage area before calling.

Avoid claiming to serve a city merely to attract leads if your business cannot reasonably provide the advertised service there.

Reclaim Your Time and Stop Wasted Ad Spend

Out-of-state phone calls don’t automatically mean your local SEO is broken. They may result from broad advertising settings, inaccurate business information, irrelevant website traffic, call tracking issues, spam, or callers whose phone numbers don’t reflect their actual locations.

The most effective approach is to identify the source before making changes.

Review your advertising settings, confirm that your business information is accurate, clarify your website’s service areas, and track which calls become qualified leads. These steps help you distinguish a genuine targeting problem from issues that require a different solution.

Use our diagnostic cheat sheet below as a quick reference guide to match your exact symptoms with the right fix:

Out-of-state call diagnostic cheat sheet
SymptomLikely causeFirst action
Calls from people searching in other statesGoogle Ads location targetingReview campaign location options and geographic reports
Calls from outside your advertised service areaLocal Services Ads targetingCheck included and excluded service areas and job types
Callers find inaccurate business detailsIncorrect Google Business Profile or directory informationCorrect the source of the inaccurate information
Callers find pages for cities you don't serveWebsite location targetingAudit location pages and clarify your actual coverage
People ask why your business called themPossible caller ID spoofingReview call records and contact your phone provider
Calls have unfamiliar area codes but plausible requestsMobile numbers or misleading geographic assumptionsConfirm the property location before rejecting the lead
Calls are attributed to the wrong marketing sourceCall tracking configurationTest tracking numbers, forwarding, and attribution
Many calls concern irrelevant servicesBroad keywords or unclear advertisingReview search terms, ad copy, and negative keywords
Customers don't understand your coverageUnclear service-area messagingMake service locations prominent on ads and landing pages
Call volume is high but few leads qualifyWeak lead-quality measurementTrack call outcomes and compare lead quality by source

By working through these failure points systematically, you can stop burning ad spend on irrelevant clicks, protect your staff’s time, and ensure your marketing setup brings in qualified local inquiries.

If you’ve checked these areas and still can’t explain why your business is receiving unwanted calls, a structured audit can help identify where to investigate next.

The goal isn’t simply to receive fewer calls. It’s to spend less time on irrelevant enquiries and more time speaking with customers you can actually serve.

Frequently Asked Questions

Why is Google showing my local business to people in other states?

Google may display your business to users outside your immediate service area depending on the search, location signals, business information, and advertising settings involved. Google Ads can also reach people who have expressed an interest in a targeted location, depending on the campaign’s location options.

Check whether the calls originate from paid advertising or organic search before changing your settings.

Can I stop Google from sending out-of-state customers to my business?

You can reduce some unwanted calls by correcting your geographic targeting, service areas, website content, and advertising settings. However, no single setting guarantees that every caller will be local.

Calls caused by spam, spoofing, or misdials require a different approach.

Should I remove my Google Business Profile service areas?

Not necessarily. You should remove areas you don’t genuinely serve, but don’t remove legitimate locations simply because some unwanted calls originate there.

Your service areas should accurately represent where your business provides services.

Does having a local phone number prevent out-of-state calls?

No. A local phone number can help establish a local presence, but it doesn’t prevent people from other states from calling. It also doesn’t guarantee that every person calling with a local area code is physically located nearby.

Should I block calls from other states?

Blocking entire states is usually a poor first response. You could inadvertently reject legitimate customers, property owners, existing clients, or people temporarily traveling outside your service area.

Identify the source and nature of the calls before deciding whether blocking or screening is appropriate.

Can local SEO help reduce unwanted calls?

Yes, when the problem involves inaccurate business information, misleading location pages, or website content that attracts irrelevant local searches. Improving those elements can help align your online presence with the services and areas you actually cover.

However, local SEO won’t fix every advertising, call tracking, spam, or phone-routing issue.

How long does it take to reduce unwanted calls?

The timeframe depends on the underlying cause. A straightforward advertising setting or incorrect phone number may be corrected relatively quickly, while changes to organic search visibility and website content can take longer to influence results.

Measure the quality of incoming calls after each significant change rather than expecting every problem to disappear immediately.

Tired of spam calls?

Get qualified calls from areas you actually serve

Find out whether your website, local search presence, or advertising setup is attracting the wrong audience. Heracles Marketing can help you identify opportunities to improve your digital marketing and attract more qualified enquiries.

Get your SEO audit today